People smuggling

Successive Australian governments have used people smuggling to attempt to criminalise asylum seekers themselves. People associate people smuggling with illegal activity, when it is not illegal to claim asylum at all.

Yet, the penalties for people smuggling offences – up to 20 years jail for boats carrying more than five passengers – are now at the level of such crimes as terrorism, rape and murder! For assisting asylum seekers!

Ali Al Jenabi, a people smuggler described as “the Oskar Schindler of Asia”

Kevin Rudd put people smuggling at the centre of his anti-refugee rhetoric in April 2009, when he declared that people smugglers were the “absolute scum of the earth”.

Yet, one of the refugees assisted by Ali Al Jenabi (whose story is told in the new book The People Smuggler) recently said, “I think he is the best smuggler. He had a good heart. He was not hard, not a greedy person”.

In 2010, the Labor government introduced legislation to create a new offence of providing advice and material support to assist an asylum seeker to get to Australia even if that assistance is entirely for humanitarian reasons. The new offence is clearly aimed at family members, refugee communities and supporters and makes them potentially subject to ASIO surveillance.

There are mandatory sentences of a minimum five years jail (of which three years must be served before any chance of parole) for people smuggling offences. While the government has stopped imposing these against the poor Indonesian fisher folk who crew the asylum boats, they are still imposed on anyone helping organise boats to Australia. This requirement has been attacked by judges for failing to account for the circumstances of those charged. In March 2014 a Victorian judge pointed out the ridiculousness of sending Lamis Hameed Sami Alli Baighi to jail, a refugee himself who helped organise his family members to get here.

Who are the smugglers?

There is no evidence that international criminal networks are organising asylum boats to Australia. Most often travel arrangements are made by local or refugee communities, motivated by a mix of profit and altruism. Indeed, several UNHCR-registered refugees have served sentences in Australian jails for people smuggling offences.

One such UNHCR Iraqi-Iranian refugee, Hadi Ahmadi, had twice attempted to get to Australia himself. In 2010 he was convicted for assisting 911 asylum seekers to come to Australia – yet 886 of them were found to be refugees.

Ten of 16 people convicted for people smuggling between 2001 and 2006 were indeed refugees themselves.

The government tries to blame a “people smugglers’ business model”– as if it was people smuggling that was driving asylum seekers to seek protection in Australia, talking of “a sophisticated million-dollar product” marketed by smugglers. But the fact is unauthorised travel to Australia is driven by the needs of people fleeing persecution in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Sri Lanka. Individuals such as Hadi Ahmadi and Ali Al Jenabi provide a humanitarian service to asylum seekers desperately needing protection but who are denied the possibility of official entry to Australia.

Many asylum seekers remain stranded en route to Australia in poor countries that have not signed the Refugee Convention and do not accept refugees, like Malaysia and Indonesia.

The simple fact is that without unauthorised travel agents, asylum seekers would not get to Australia.

Government policy costs lives

Governments are now trying to claim the humanitarian high ground, saying that efforts to “stop the boats” are designed to stop asylum seekers making dangerous boat journeys and avoid deaths at sea. They are nothing of the sort.

In fact the government’s “deterrence” policies and its criminalisation of people smuggling makes boat journeys to Australia much more dangerous. Australia has been pressuring the Indonesian government to imprison and harass asylum seekers in order to “stop the boats”.

The Australian government has funded the upgrade of Indonesian detention centres and announced $654 million in 2009-10 to work with Indonesia and other countries in the region to “combat people smuggling”. This means asylum seekers are forced to find a way to escape Indonesia as quickly as possible, and take the risk of getting on unsafe boats.

The fact that Australia impounds and destroys the vessels that bring asylum seekers here means they are more likely to be unseaworthy—as the crossing from Indonesia is the boats’ last voyage. The Labor government’s people smuggling laws are nothing but an attempt to compete with the Liberals to demonise refugees.

Almost all the deaths at sea have been caused by the appalling response of Australia’s search and rescue services, who have been told to prioritise stopping boats, not saving lives. Tony Kevin, author of Reluctant Rescuers, has written that the “rescue response is ad hoc and unpredictable… we act when we choose to”. As a result, “Hundreds of people have died when they could and should have been saved”.

As recently as June 5, 2013, at least 55 drowned due to the lack of response from the authorities. Although the boat’s engines were dead when it spotted on Wednesday, it was only 40 hours later that Border Protection Command alerted the search and rescue authorities. This is a continual pattern. In July customs waited over five hours after getting a distress signal before directing one of its ships to go to rescue an asylum boat. Nine people are thought to have died.

Processing in Indonesia

Unless there are alternative routes to permanent resettlement in Australia, asylum seekers will have no option but to take boats from Indonesia to Australia. If the government processed asylum claims directly in Indonesia and guaranteed resettlement in Australia, there would be no need for asylum seekers to risk boat journeys.

But successive governments have refused to systemically resettle refugees from Indonesia.

Between 2001 and 2009 Australia accepted just 532 people – an average of less than 60 a year. In recent years it has raised the level slightly, accepting 500 one year in 2010-11 and raising its intake to 600 in the last year (Senate Estimates, Legal and Constitutional Committee, 27 May 2013, p108). But this goes nowhere near dealing with the number of asylum seekers stranded in Indonesia. In July 2014 the UNHCR said there were 5564 registered asylum seekers and 3983 recognised refugees in Indonesia.

The government’s own Expert Panel recommended raising the refugee intake to 3200 people “from the region” a year to deal with this problem, but the government has failed to act. Its quota for refugees from Malaysia and Indonesia remains only 1850 a year (and the 1000 from Malaysia were signed up to under the ill-fated Malaysia Agreement).

But regardless of the alternative measures put in place, there may still be asylum boats that continue to need to travel to Australia. For example boats have travelled from their persecuters in Sri Lanka directly to Australia. All of them should be welcomed—and there are real measures the government could take if it was serious about saving lives, not about punishing people and trying to stop them coming.

Updated August 2014

Other articles and fact sheets on people smuggling

Les Murray, host of SBS soccer, escaped Hungary in 1956 with the aid of a people smuggler, and returned there last year with SBS’s Dateline program to try to find the smuggler who he says saved his life and thank him. Read about his story in The Sydney Morning Herald or watch the program on SBS’s website

The Asylum Seeker Resource Centre’s fact sheet on people smuggling

Ali Al Jenabi, “the Oskar Schindler of Asia” was a people smuggler in Indonesia who worked for humanitarian motives, and in order to get his own family to safety.

Bruce Haigh, “People Smuggler of the Schindler of Asia” ABC’s The Drum

“The story of Ali Al Jenabi” Late Nate Live (interview with author of The People Smuggler Robin De Crespigny) MP3 available

Responses to Four Corners program

It is the government, not people smugglers, that has blood on its hands, Refugee Action Coalition

Abdul Khadem: the real story, Refugee Action Coalition